THE COALITION
  • Home
  • Past Shows
    • LIVE Broadcast
    • Gina Raimondo Political Hall O' Shame Inductee William Murray Cumberland Mayor 6/9/17
    • Alicia Ann Kelley - Environmental Activist
    • Rob Cote - Activist Extraordinaire
    • Bobby "The Rep" Nardolillo Candidate-US Senate
    • Arvin Vohra LP National Vice Chair 05/19/17
    • Emerge America Political Director A'shanti Gholar
    • Shannah Kurland \\ PrYSM: Community Safety Act
    • The Debate! Jared Moffat Regulate RI vs. MIchael Cerullo RI Center For Freedom & Prosperity
    • FIT: Meg Kerr\\RIPTA Riders-Pawtucket Soup Kitchen
    • Frank Carini -EcoRI.org
    • Attny's McElroy & Elmer: Invenergy!
    • Lynnette Labinger - ACLU / Donna Personeus Thayer St!
    • Jared Moffat Regulate RI
    • Jon Keith - Rhode Island Senate District 27
    • Homeless Bill of Rights Committee September 17, 2016
    • Republicans For Johnson\\\\Weld August 28, 2016
    • Rep Sherry Roberts: Quiet Strength\\Monique Chartier-Freedom & Prosperity\\Daryl Gould LP Candidate GA @ The Superman
    • Analee Berretto: Libertarian Candidate General Assembly Bristol / Portsmouth
    • Charles Wilson - National Association of Black Law Enforcement Officers
    • Linda Lotridge Levin- Rhode Island Press Association
    • Pride Week! Thom Simmons LP Candidate US Congress / Mike Shipley Outright Libertarians
    • New England Livery: Uber & The Sharing Economy / Del BigTree Vaxxed The Movie
    • Alex Merced Libertarian For US Senate New York-Joanne Leppanen RIPAC Cannabis Tax Crisis
    • Steve Kerbel / Gary Johnson Libertarian Candidate
    • Phil West\\Bill Felkner CLEANRI.org The Ethics Bill 5/14/16
    • Darryl Perry: Libertarian Candidate for the Presidency of the United States
    • CoHost Blake Filippi \\Gary Sasse Represents John Kasich \\Joe Trillo Represents Donald Trump
    • John McAfee: Libertarian Warrior / Candidate for The Presidency of the United States
    • Austin Petersen: Libertarian Candidate for POTUS \\\\ Jame Kennedy TransportPVD
    • Prof Steven Forleo Rocks Corporate Academia
    • Blake Filippi Libertarian Lion
    • CLEAN RI Bill Felkner
    • Moira Walsh Candidate District 3/RIPTA Riders/Fung Fiasco!
    • State of Homelessness-Rhode Island
    • Emergency Medical Cannabis Summit!
    • Bob Lafleur: Rhode Island Independent Contractors
    • Bella Robinson-Coyote / Norma Jean Almodovar Sex Worker Rights Activist
    • StopTollsRI.com / Rep Pat Morgan
    • Michael G Riley Explains It All To You-Pension Crisis Redux
    • J. Kennedy/J. Harris The 6/10 Connector: Boulevard of Dreams?
    • Bella Robinson\\Maxine Doogan Decriminalize!
    • Dr. Beshara Doumani - Syria! 12/5/15
    • The Curious Case O' The Dancing Cop Moore v. Stewart: Presiding Judge Ford
    • RIPTA Riders Alliance/James Kennedy
    • Joan Chabot Candidate Senate District 11/Hillary Davis: RI ACLU
    • Jim Vickers-Manchester 65\\ Greenwich Cove Meadery October 24, 2015
    • Jim Vincent Providence NAACP October 10, 2015
    • Providence Apartment Association\\\\Monique Chartier December 3, 2015
    • John Miner Russ Moore Alex Merced August 26, 2015
    • Shannah Kurland September 19, 2015
    • Kate Nagle Michael Riley September 12, 2015
    • Providence Bankruptcy! 9/21/14 Riley/Harrop/Flanders The Experts Weigh In!
    • Bob Healey: The Cool Moose 10/12/14
    • The Coalition Episode 5
    • Podcast
    • The Coalition Condensed
  • Advertise
  • Civil Liberty News!
    • PO Taxpayer
    • Tony Jones
    • David Fisher
    • The Goldwater Institute
  • Fight the Stadium
  • YOU! Need To Join The ACLU
  • About Us
    • Hosts
    • In The News
    • Contact Us
    • Media Partners
    • Sponsors
  • LIVE Broadcast
  • Our Next Show
  • Coalition YouTube Page
  • The Coalition Podcast!

The Spoiler Myth Debunked

11/23/2014

Comments

 
It seems Rhode Island conservatives are still a bit sore over Allan Fung's loss in the recent gubernatorial election, and many of them are choosing to blame Bob Healey as the "spoiler" in the race. Fung supporters seem to think that Healey took twice as many votes from Fung as Raimondo, but upon closer inspection, it seems that very few potential Fung voters opted for the Cool Moose instead

In West Greenwich, for instance, Fung won with 1,097 votes; Raimondo took 684 and Healey took 605. In comparison, the Republican candidates for U.S. Congress in the district - Rhue Reis and Mark Zaccaria - took 1,187 and 1,081 respectively. The Democrats in those races - Reed and Langevin - took 1,291 and 1,178 respectively. It seems that in West Greenwich, Fung took nearly all of his base voters, while Healey split potential Raimondo supporters down the middle.

In North Smithfield, the song remains the same:

Raimondo - 1,456             Dem. for U.S. Congress (avg.) - 2,421
Fung - 1,870                     Rep. for U.S. Congress (avg.) - 1,871
Healey - 986

In Narragansett, it appears that Healey took a couple of hundred votes from Fung and over 1,000 from Raimondo:

Raimondo - 2,395            Dem. for U.S. Congress (avg.) - 3,795
Fung - 2,410                    Rep. for U.S. Congress (avg.) - 2,149
Healey - 1,198


Even in Providence *, the Republican base seems unshakable, with Fung far outperforming the candidates for congress, and Healey's votes seeming to appear out of the ether:

Raimondo - 24,662            Dem. for U.S. Congress (avg.) - 24,072
Fung - 8,445                      Rep. for U.S. Congress (avg.) - 3,568
Healey - 4,116

When you look at the election numbers on a district by party basis, it seems that Healey did not cost Fung the election; he cost Raimondo a mandate. In addition to the numbers, I'll offer you the sage words of my friend and statistics uber-wonk, Eric Siegel:
 
Truth: A tiny fraction over 60% of Healey votes (60.4442%) would have had to have gone to Fung instead for the result to have been a tie. But that takes us back to the whole "spoiler" question, which is that if a candidate doesn't get the votes, it means they didn't earn the votes, not that they were "stolen" by another candidate. That assumes that votes belong to candidates and/or parties, not voters.
So there yo have it. R.I. Republicans should take their gains on the national level and in the General Assembly and STFU. With the spoiler myth debunked, and the master lever gone in the next election cycle, they'll have no more bogeymen to blame for "costing us an election" and might actually have to admit that Rhode Island voters don't like their policies or politicians. The next time someone tells you that Fung only lost because Healey "stole" his votes, tell them that it's impossible to steal something from someone that didn't have that thing in the first place. Better yet, send them a link to this blog post!

Don't fault people for voting their conscience rather than for the lesser of two evils. The country would be a much better place if we collectively did just that.

* According to the R.I. Board of Elections, Providence election returns are not all in.
Comments

    RSS Feed

    Picture

    Dave Fisher

    I am the burr under your saddle. I am the rock in your shoe. I am the limb that appears out of nowhere while you're walking in the woods that you almost walk into and take your eye out. I will afflict the comfortable, comfort the afflicted, and offend those I find offensive. Nothing is true. Everything is permitted.

      Email me!

    Submit
    Tweets about "@DAFisherRI"

    Archives

    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014

    Categories

    All
    1st Amendment
    Baldelli-Hunt
    Bernie Sanders
    #blacklivesmatter
    Black Lives Matter
    Blight
    Bureaucracy
    Buying Votes
    Campaign Finance
    Casey
    Chickens
    Chippendale
    Civil Liberties
    C. Montgomery Burns
    Constitution
    Corruption
    Costa
    Crony Capitalism
    Crony Corporatism
    CVS
    DINO
    Electioneering
    Election Fraud
    Ethics
    Fascism
    Felony
    Flexibility
    Funny
    Gina Raimondo
    GoLocalProv
    Graffiti
    Green Party
    Greens
    Hate Speech
    Highway Blocking
    I-195 Land
    I-195 Redevelopment Commission
    Income Inequality
    Islamic
    #Jill2016
    Jill Stein
    #JobsBudget
    Kettle
    Larry Lucchino
    Legislative Grants
    Mattiello
    Maximum Wage
    McCoy
    Minimum Wage
    Morin
    Muslim
    Nazi
    Newberry
    #NoPVDStadium
    Party
    Pawtucket Red Sox
    Phillips
    Progressive
    Protest
    Raptakis
    Religious Right
    Renamed
    Representative Raymond Hull
    Republican Party
    Rhode ISland
    RIFUTURE
    Route 99
    Satire
    School
    Senator Lou Raptakis
    Skeffington
    Skeffo-nomics
    Stadium
    Steve Ahlquist
    Subsidies
    Taxes
    Tea Party
    Thugs
    Transparency
    Trillo
    Vandalism
    Voter Fraud
    Wealth Inequality
    West Warwick
    Woonsocket
    Zoning

    RSS Feed

Picture
Picture
Picture

Picture